Configuring Domain Security on Exchange Server 2013

Configuring Domain Security on Exchange Server 2013

A need to protect SMTP traffic is not uncommon. In general, you can’t always protect it. Inside your organization, it’s pretty easy – you can easily implement digital signatures or encryption for emails, but if you want to go outside, things are becoming more complicated. You can still use digital signing (S/MIME) on emails, but if your certificate is issued by your internal PKI, it probably won’t be trusted on recipient side. That will not prevent functionality of digital signature, but will affect trust.
 
If you want to send encrypted emails outside your organization, things are even more complicated. If you want to use just built-in Outlook features for message encryption, you will need to have public key of any recipient that you want to send encrypted message to. Inside your organization, this is not an issue as you can publish certificates in AD DS. However, outside, on the Internet this is not an easy job. Sure, there are some third party tools for this, but let’s see what we can do without them.
 
Domain Security is a feature of Exchange Server (both 2010 and 2013) that can secure SMTP traffic between two Exchange organizations. It is implemented on server level, and it works without configuring any options on user (sender or recipient) side. Domain Security uses mutual TLS authentication to provide session-based authentication and encryption. Mutual TLS authentication is different from TLS as it’s usually implemented. Usually, when you implement TLS, client will verify the server certificate, and authenticate the server, before establishing a connection.
 
With mutual TLS authentication, each server verifies the connection with the other server by validating a certificate that’s provided by that other server, so clients are not included at all. We establish secure SMTP channel between two Exchange Servers, usually over the Internet.
Clients, Outlook and Outlook Web App, will be aware that Domain Security is established. Green icon with check mark will be shown on each messages exchanged between servers on which Domain Security is implemented.

 

As you can see, Domain Security can be applied between two (or more) known Exchange organizations. Still, it can’t protect whole SMTP traffic that comes and goes from your Exchange organization, but it can efficiently protect SMTP traffic between partner organizations.
 
Let’s see how to configure it. I’ll show the procedure for Exchange Server 2013, but most of it can be applied to Exchange Server 2010 also. Let’s assume that we want to establish Domain Security between two Exchange organizations named adatum.com and treyresearch.net (Yes, I’m using domain names from Microsoft Learning courses, but since I write these courses, I just get used to that 
Smile)
 
1. Establish certificate trust between organizations
As said before, Domain Security relies on certificates. Because of this, you should first establish certificate trust between two organizations where you want to implement Domain Security. You can do it on several ways. If both organizations are using publicly trusted certificate on Exchange servers, you are good to go. If that’s not the case you will have to cross-import Root CA certificates on both sides. Alternatively, you can also issue certificates for SMTP for both Exchange organization from a single trusted RootCA. Anyway, the point is that each Exchange server must trust the certificate installed (and assigned to SMTP service) on another Exchange server. Achieve this in any way you like. Besides establishing trust, make sure that certificate common name is same as the name that Exchange server provides in HELO/EHLO conversation.
 
However, it’s important to notice one thing here. In Exchange Server 2010, you would be doing this on Edge Transport server or if you didn’t deploy one, on Hub Transport server. Since these two roles are no more in Exchange 2013, these certificates should be installed on CAS servers which, in Exchange Server 2013, host FrontEnd Transport Service. Also, it is important that certificate you want to use for Domain Security is assigned to SMTP (it can be assigned to other services as well)
  

2. Configure Domain Security
As both sides/companies will be sending and receiving emails, following procedure should be done on both sides, but domain names should be used vice-versa.
 
First, open Exchange Management Shell and execute this cmdlet :

Get-TransportConfig | FL
 
You will get whole list of transport settings but we want two of them : TLSReceiveDomainSecureList and TLSSendDomainSecureList. If you were not configuring Domain Security so far, you will have these two values empty. To use Domain Security we must populate these parameters with appropriate values.
TLSReceiveDomainSecureList – specifies the domains from which you want to receive domain secured email by using mutual Transport Layer Security (TLS) authentication
TLSSendDomainSecureList – specifies the domains from which you want to send domain secured email by using mutual TLS authentication
 
If we are on adatum.com side, we will execute following:
Set-TransportConfig -TLSSendDomainSecureList adatum.com and
Set-TransportConfig –TLSReceiveDomainSecureList treyresereach.net
 
After this, when you run the Get cmdlet again you should have these values:
 

 
Logically, on treyresearch side we will issue same commands but domains will be inverted. If you have more than one company with requirement for Domain Security, you can provide their domain names too. This cmdlet accepts multivalued parameters.
 
3. Configure connectors
Now, we will create dedicated connectors for Domain Security. Let’s first create the send connector. You can use Exchange Admin center for this. Navigate to mail flow, click Send connectors and add new one. In a wizard, type the name of the connector and select Partner type. Don’t use the smart host, but leave MX record as a method to send mail. For connector address space, type the domain name from other Exchange organization. If you are on Adatum.com side, you will type treyresearch.net. On the source server page of wizard, select Mailbox server that you want to use as a source. It doesn’t matter which one you will choose since we will configure connector to proxy through CAS. When you create the connector, double click it and then enable options “Proxy through client access server”. You can also configure maximum message size for this connector if you want, and enable protocol logging.
 

 
Now back to Exchange Management Shell,and execute :
Get-SendConnector –identity ConnectorName | FL
 
Look for the value of parameter DomainSecureEnabled. It should be True. If it’s not you can easily set it with Set-SendConnector –identityConnectorName –DomainSecureEnabled:$true
 
Let’s now configure Receive connector. Back to EAC, click mail flow and then click receive connectors. In Select server drop-down list choose your Client Access server.
 
Select Partner for connector type, configure receiving IP address if you want (or just leave all available) but on remote network settings page, you should configure only the IP address assigned to another organization Exchange server. This should be (public) IP from which partner’s Exchange server sends email. After you create the connector double click it, and click on security tab. Make sure that authentication options are set like on following screenshot.
  

 
4. Test the Domain Security
Easiest way to test this is to just send email from one organization to another from Outlook. If you get the message with green check mark, you are all set. If not, then you’ll need some troubleshooting. You can enable protocol logging by executing :
Set-ReceiveConnector Internet -ProtocolLoggingLevel Verbose, and
Set-SendConnector Internet -ProtocolLoggingLevel Verbose
to verify TLS channel. If message doesn’t arrive to recipient but doesn’t come back as NDR, you should check queue.
  
Leave a Comment
  • Please add 7 and 6 and type the answer here:
  • Post
Wiki - Revision Comment List(Revision Comment)
Sort by: Published Date | Most Recent | Most Useful
Comments
  • Ed Price - MSFT edited Revision 1. Comment: white space

Page 1 of 1 (1 items)
Wikis - Comment List
Sort by: Published Date | Most Recent | Most Useful
Posting comments is temporarily disabled until 10:00am PST on Saturday, December 14th. Thank you for your patience.
Comments
  • Hi!

    First I want to say thanks for this article.

    Can you please advise if there is still the certificate requirement to have the appropriate domain names within the SAN area of the certificate to be able to use Mutual TLS?

    E.g. we tried to use Mutual TLS with out Exchange 2010 against a company routing their messages through Exchange Online Protection and Mutual TLS never worked as our Edge server always said, that the recipients domain is missing in the certificates name.

    In fact we were unable to establish the Mutual TLS (or "forced TLS", how they called it) with any company who asked us to do so because of the certificate requirements...

    Best regards,

    Michael

  • Hi Michael,

    Yes, you must have appropriate names in certificate. Actually, certificate that you assign to SMTP service must have the exact same name that your SMTP connector (created for Domain Security) is using.

  • Ed Price - MSFT edited Revision 1. Comment: white space

  • Hi Damir,

    Thanks for your quick reply!

    So currently there seems to be no option to "force TLS" with partners relaying through EOP or other services which do not have the recipient domains on the accepting smtp server certificate with the implemenation of "Mutual TLS"?

    Maybe, do you know if EOP or FOPE works the same way? The documentation here is not exect precise:

    technet.microsoft.com/.../jj723154.aspx

    What I am exactly curious about is, what does this one mean:

    For Connection Security, specify Recipient certificate matches domain. Enter the domain name of the recipient in the Certificate domain field. For Outbound Delivery, choose MX record associated with the recipient domain.

    Assuming I have EOP and my partner company also, so our mx records point to Microsoft servers and not to our own envrionment. Will we be able to secure the transfer with TLS between both domains with a force TLS as our domains will never show up on the Microsoft mail server certificates.

    We have the possibility the move on to EOP from our EA and currently there is a decision to be made regarding this...

    I know this is a comment box and no support forum but maybe other people have the same questions and I appreciate any answer :)

    Best regards,

    Michael

  • Finally I found a workaround for half the problem myself by creating a new send connector where I can put in the domains I require outbound TLS with a lower cost value and the setting RequireTLS as true.

    The only requirement from the remote server is a StartTLS command and no certificate is checked during this process. If no StartTLS is offered, mails will be stuck in the queue until the TTL is reached or the remote server offers TLS. Not exactly the same as Mutual TLS but at least a workaround to secure stuff we send.

    The opposite partner has to make sure that they send TLS encrypted as well and your're good to go with "MutualTLS light".

    Best regards,

    Michael

Page 1 of 1 (5 items)